Chelsea Handler is a comedian who’s made a name for herself as the host of Chelsea Lately on E!, a late night roundtable/talk show where comedians mercilessly mock celebrities that have shown up in E! News stories and I assume the Enquirer and People, and then Handler interviews a different one afterwards. Some time later, a mock behind-the-scenes show called After Lately. Her humor is brash, sarcastic, sharp-tongued, witty, and at times very filthy, and this is what has made her popular. So popular in fact, that she has been given her own sitcom.
The (second) pilot aired last night on NBC. Are You There, Chelsea? Is based on Handler’s autobiographical books “Are You There Vodka, It’s Me Chelsea,” “My My Horizontal Life: A Collection of One-Night Stands,” and “Chelsea Chelsea Bang Bang.” The show initially had the title of one of the three aforementioned books, but can’t you just imagine some NBC executive looking down a long desk at Handler and the show’s producers and telling them, “We can’t have the word ‘vodka’ in a primetime show on this network. Let’s play with the words a little. And, while we’re at it…”
Laura Prepon plays a younger Chelsea Handler, while Handler plays her older sister Sloan [yes, I’m serious]. Rounding out the cast are Ali Wong as the minority best friend; Lauren Lapkus as the dorky, virgin, cringe-eliciting roommate (cringe comedy is guaranteed to be funny, right, Office?), Jake MacDormand as the handsome bartender who Chelsea (Prepon) tried to sleep with one night, but it didn’t work because they both wanted to be on top; Mark Povellini as the colorblind little person barback; and Lenny Clarke as Chelsea and Sloan’s dad Melvin.
The show is more formulaic than anything I ever would have expected Handler to be involved with, and falls flat almost constantly. Programs like The League, Archer, and It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia on FX have taught audiences, as well as writers and television producers, something that I’ve known for years: crude, lewd, and dirty can be hilarious. What the writers and producers of Are You There, Chelsea? did not learn is that having a character simply say or do something crude, lewd, and dirty is not automatically hilarious. That type of humor takes a certain panache to pull off, which interestingly is something that Handler herself has, but this show does not. Maybe that’s just something one should expect from a show based on Handler’s work but created by Dharma & Greg veterans Julie Ann Larson and Dottie Zicklin. Are You There, Chelsea? seems to want very badly to be like one of those FX comedies, but I get a sense that it may have “needed” to be watered down in order to be shown on one of the big four networks during primetime. Indeed the show was heavily reworked since NBC execs saw the first pilot, and I have to wonder if they toned down the crudeness, and in so doing, the humor and any real wit or charm the show might have had, as well.
One can kind of see through all the nonsense that Laura Prepon is still a very talented comedic actress, but she is very miscast as this 26-year-old television version of Handler who works at a bar, drinks a lot, sleeps around, gets arrested and kisses a very butch lesbian in jail to get out of being beaten up, actually prays to the deity known as Vodka, and delivers really clunky and probably unnecessary narration. Handler’s character Sloan [I hope you’re not confused] doesn’t seem to work as the overly religious new mom (pregnant until the end of last night’s episode) she’s supposed to be, and has most of the wit, sarcasm, and lines that work reserved for herself. It could just be that I’m a huge fan of Rescue Me and the man’s stand-up, but I found Lenny Clarke to be the only real shining light on the show. Clarke isn’t given the best material to work with, or much material at all in that first episode, but his performance is so damn funny, anyway. It seems like such waste of a comedian of that caliber to stick him on a mediocre and just kind of stupid television show as the dad.
I like Chelsea Handler, and I really really wanted to like this show. Hell, I even found something good about it (Thank you, Lenny Clarke), but the mediocrity and stupid far outweighs what’s good, and I doubt I’m going to give this another viewing. Next week, another female comedian whose act I thoroughly enjoy and a good friend of Handler, Natasha Leggero is apparently slated to appear, and I fear watching her try to make the best of stupid lines in stupidly written situation comedy that’s about as edgy as a tennis ball. Or she’ll get great lines, put her fantastic sense of comedic timing to use, and I’d wind up having to suffer through the parts of the show in between her appearances. It’s not worth it.